RSS | Advertise With Us | Blogs | Judaica Gifts  16 Sivan 5769, Monday, June 8, 2009 22:15 IST |
Home Headlines Iranian Threat Jewish World Opinion Business Real Estate Local Israel Blogs Arts & Culture Français Classifieds
Israel Middle East International Health & Sci-Tech Features Travel Cafe Oleh Magazine Sports Israel Guide Subscribe
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers a 20% discount on online reservations
Think Healthy
Minerals Dead Sea cosmetics, special offers online!
The Best Jewish Charity
Learn how Efrat saved 30,000 lives of Jewish children
Tamir Rent a car
Car rental in Israel, special prices
Find love at
Use your mouse to find your spouse!
Israel guide
Your guide to Israel
Green Israel
Protecting Israel's environment
The future of music
Global community of music makers discover new music » Opinion » Editorials » Article

Why Obama is wrong on Israel and the Shoah

Print Subscribe
+ Recommend:
facebook reddit newsvine fark
What's this?

Decrease text size Decrease text size
Increase text size Increase text size

On Friday, President Barack Obama placed a single white flower at the Buchenwald memorial for the estimated 43,000 people - among them 11,000 Jews - murdered at the concentration camp. In subdued tones, he said that the passage of time had not made the crematoria lose their horror. He spoke of his great uncle, who under Gen. Dwight Eisenhower had been among the camp's liberators. He recounted how Eisenhower had toured the camp so he could personally challenge anyone who might claim that the Allies had exaggerated the Nazi horrors for propaganda purposes.

US President Barack Obama,...

US President Barack Obama, second right, and German Chancellor Angela Merkel, second left, listen to Holocaust survivors Elie Wiesel, right, and Bertrand Herz, left, during a visit to the former Buchenwald Nazi concentration camp near the eastern German city of Weimar.
Photo: AP

This gave Obama another opportunity to declare that Holocaust denial is "baseless," "ignorant" and "hateful."

In his Cairo address the day before to the Muslim and Arab worlds, the president had justified Israel's right to exist on the basis of the Holocaust: "The aspiration for a Jewish homeland is rooted," he said, "in a tragic history" that culminated in the Shoah.

At Buchenwald, he said: "The nation of Israel [arose] out of the destruction of the Holocaust."

That rationale, standing alone, set the stage for Obama to assert: "On the other hand, it is also undeniable that the Palestinians… have suffered in pursuit of a homeland."

BARACK OBAMA has been terribly misinformed if he thinks Israel's legitimacy hinges on the Shoah. Of course, had the Jews achieved a national homeland in Palestine before the outbreak of WWII - as Britain promised in the 1917 Balfour Declaration and as the League of Nations affirmed in 1920 - the doors to this country would not have been barred to Jewish refugees seeking to escape from the Nazi killing machine. History would have turned out very differently indeed.

What the Holocaust proved is that the world is too dangerous a place for Jews to be stateless and defenseless. But we Zionists were making that argument long before Hitler came to power.

Granted, modern political Zionism developed in the late 1800s and early 1900s. But the president needs to better appreciate that Israel's legitimacy is not dependent on the consequences of the war waged against the Jews between 1933 and 1945. It is, first and foremost, rooted in the historic connection of the Jewish people to the Land of Israel.

The Zionist movement rejected Uganda as a safe haven in 1903, the need to save Jews from violent anti-Semitism notwithstanding, because Uganda did not belong to the Jews.

However one chooses to understand Jewish civilization - as sacred history, or through the modern lenses of secular history and archeology - the ancient bond between the Jews and their land is indisputable.

By 1000 BCE, the Twelve Tribes had formed a united monarchy. Then, when in 586 BCE the Jews were defeated and exiled, "By the rivers of Babylon... we sat down, yea, we wept, when we remembered Zion." We returned and rebuilt our commonwealth - only to be defeated and exiled again, in 70 CE. As early as the 9th century, Jews had reestablished communities in Tiberias; and, in the 11th century, in Gaza.

SO YOU see, Mr. President, long before Christianity and Islam appeared on the world stage, the covenant between the people of Israel and the Land of Israel was entrenched and unwavering. Every day we prayed in our ancient tongue for our return to Zion. Every day, Mr. President. For 2,000 years.

At every Jewish wedding down through the centuries, the bridegroom has crushed a glass beneath his foot while declaring: "If I forget thee, O Jerusalem…"

Perhaps it's because Palestine was never sovereign under the Arabs that even moderate Palestinians cannot find it in their hearts to acknowledge the depth of the Jews' connection to Zion. Instead, they insist we are interlopers.

When Obama implies that Jewish rights are essentially predicated on the Holocaust - not once asserting they are far, far deeper and more ancient - he is dooming the prospects for peace.

For why should the Arabs reconcile themselves to the presence of a Jewish state, organic to the region, when the US president keeps insinuating that Israel was established to atone for Europe's crimes?

Print Subscribe
+ Recommend:
facebook reddit newsvine fark
What's this?
Post comment | Terms | Report Abuse
52. Exile
Howard Abarbanel - USA (06/08/2009 20:55)
51. Eisenhower
George Jochnowitz - USA (06/08/2009 20:50)
50. The Cairo Speech
Chaskel Bennett - usa (06/08/2009 20:40)
49. Jens - Demark
David - US (06/08/2009 20:27)
48. Why?
LV - USA (06/08/2009 20:24)
47. Noone is against the presence of jews in that piece of land and it is understandable that they are attached to it
H.Ali - (06/08/2009 20:24)
46. Mike Germany
David - US (06/08/2009 20:23)
45. Jens' rubbish about Palestinians' "inalienable rights"
Raymond in DC - USA (06/08/2009 20:20)
44. How could someone call themselves a "Historian" (see #26) and then...
Czarkazem13 - (06/08/2009 19:26)
43. Obama's game of chess
YZK - USA (06/08/2009 19:09)
42. SHOAH is a Hebrew word and non Jews and non Israelis should not use it nor appropriate it. For them it is always HOLOCAUST. Even for the jpost.
L.S.B. - (06/08/2009 19:02)
41. Comment on #22 Exile
Danny - UK (06/08/2009 19:01)
40. we miss you Mr Bush. The best US president ever!
e - (06/08/2009 18:38)
39. The Covenant of the Land
Elizabeth Kirkley Best PhD - USA (06/08/2009 18:35)
38. To Jens in Denmark
Jackiekc - (06/08/2009 18:30)
37. Brilliant Article!
Amos - Israel (06/08/2009 18:20)
36. Keep saying it...but (cont.)
Hofikoman - USA (06/08/2009 18:20)
35. ....maybe, be Obama's right on spot regarding settlements.
Mike - Germany (06/08/2009 18:11)
34. Keep saying it ...but
Hofikoman - USA (06/08/2009 18:11)
33. ha - obama gets the holocuast HA
kov - (06/08/2009 18:07)
32. to #15
Chris - Israel (06/08/2009 17:54)
31. Why do you limit it to just "on Israel"?
Frank Molnar - USA (06/08/2009 17:47)
30. #8 and 15 missing the point
TR - USA (06/08/2009 17:46)
29. #5 Historic error?
Richard Brown - United States (06/08/2009 17:45)
28. obama on shoah and israel
moron - galut (06/08/2009 17:37)
andrew - usa (06/08/2009 16:45)
26. If Obama were a Christian . . .
Historian - (06/08/2009 16:45)
25. The Way It Is
Ray Joseph Cormier - Canada (06/08/2009 16:42)
24. Palis Aways Had Homelands
Beth Goodtree - USA (06/08/2009 16:39)
23. Common Ground
Zundel - (06/08/2009 16:27)
KKL Picture of the week
Got a Question?
Have a question about something in this story? Ask it here and get answers from other users like you.

© 1995 - 2009 The Jerusalem Post. All rights reserved.    About Us | Media Kit | Exclusive Content | Advertise with Us | Subscribe | Contact Us | RSS
The online edition of The Jerusalem Post – – provides first class news and analysis about Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world. Whether news about Iran, Gaza, Syria, Fatah, Hamas or Hezbollah, covers the burning issues of the Middle East and the Israeli-Arab conflict.